ARCHAEOMALACOLOGY · 4
In grave 43 of the Varna cemetery, on the Bulgarian coast of the Black Sea, a man aged between forty and fifty wore on his left forearm a bracelet cut from a shell. It had broken in two, and the pieces had been joined again with small plates of gold. This is the richest burial in the cemetery, John Chapman, Tom Higham and colleagues wrote in the European Journal of Archaeology in 2006, and around the body lay gold earrings, bracelets and appliqués. Radiocarbon dates published by the same team a year later place the use of the cemetery between 4560 and 4450 BC.
The shell is Spondylus gaederopus, the Mediterranean thorny oyster. It does not live in the Black Sea, whose waters are too cold and not salty enough, as the CNRS archaeologist Michel Séfériadès points out. Yet Varna has yielded some 1,100 ornaments made from it, among them bracelets, necklaces and appliqués sewn onto clothing. The question has two parts. How can anyone tell which sea a shell came from when it turns up in a grave hundreds or thousands of kilometres inland, and what did it mean to wear one on the arm?
The animal is a bivalve that cements itself to rock at depths of two to thirty metres. Its valves are thick and its hinge sturdy, so the shell yields beads, pendants and rings wide enough to slip a hand through. Séfériadès adds a detail that matters. The red or orange colour fades when a shell lies on a beach for long, and the best pieces were taken by diving and prising live animals from the seabed.
The spread is huge. In 2019 Arne Windler, of the Deutsches Bergbau-Museum in Bochum, published in the Journal of Open Archaeology Data a database of 489 sites and 8,037 objects across twenty-two countries, from the Aegean and the Adriatic to the Paris Basin. Use peaks around 5000 BC, when the shells appear all over Europe. The communities of the Linear Pottery culture, the first farmers of central Europe, took them up between 5500 and 5000. In the early centuries of the fifth millennium the centre of gravity lies along the Tisza and the Danube, then slides towards the Black Sea coast, where Varna stands.
Here lies the difficulty. Spondylus also exists as a fossil, in the sediments of seas that vanished millions of years ago, and in Hungary Miocene beds are known some fifty kilometres from certain Neolithic villages. A fossil shell picked up in the hills would have spared the journey to the coast. The idea resurfaced as late as 2006 and 2009, and it was not absurd.
The first answer came in 1970. Writing in Nature, Nicholas Shackleton, a Quaternary geologist at Cambridge, and the archaeologist Colin Renfrew measured oxygen isotopes in ornaments from the Balkans. The principle is simple. The mollusc builds its shell from the oxygen in the water around it, and the proportion of heavy to light oxygen depends on temperature and salinity. Black Sea water, diluted by rivers, leaves a lighter signature in the carbonate than Aegean water does. The sample was small, nine objects from four sites in Bulgaria, Greece and Serbia, according to an account published in 2013. It was enough to point to the Mediterranean. In the same paper the two authors suggested reading the traffic as an exchange of gifts.
Oxygen says nothing about a shell's age. To rule out fossils, Nicholas Shackleton and Henry Elderfield turned to strontium in Antiquity in 1990. The ratio between two of its isotopes in seawater has shifted over geological time along a known curve, and a shell records it. Three Neolithic ornaments and a fossil specimen, the 2013 study reports, gave different values, and the ornaments came out as recent. In 2020 Aldona Kurzawska and Iwona Sobkowiak-Tabaka used the same method, in Sprawozdania Archeologiczne, on a medallion found at Karsko in Poland. It resembled an Oligocene species, but strontium placed it in the Quaternary, the age of the people who wore it.
The most thorough check came from Bernadett Bajnóczi and colleagues in the Journal of Archaeological Science in 2013. The Hungarian and Greek team analysed 21 objects from the Late Neolithic cemetery of Aszód, some forty kilometres from Budapest, and compared them with fifteen finds from Greek sites, with modern shells from the Aegean and the Adriatic and with fossil shells from the region. The oxygen values from Aszód overlap with those of both seas. The authors then examined the material by cathodoluminescence, which means lighting it with an electron beam that makes minerals altered over time glow differently. The beads keep their original aragonite and show none of the calcite that forms in fossils. They were fresh shells. One limit is stated openly, since the Aegean and the Adriatic have signatures too similar to separate, and the authors point to trace elements as the way to do it.
Where were they worked? At Dimini, in Thessaly, the archaeologist Paul Halstead re-examined in 1993, again in Antiquity, rings, buttons and beads together with the manufacturing waste of a community that processed the shell on site. But Séfériadès also lists workshops far from the coast, from European Turkey to Romania, where shells arrived whole and were cut and reworked. A Polish finding counsels caution. Many small discs published as Spondylus were in fact made from freshwater mussels, and in Poland the confirmed pieces number seven, from five sites.
Italy has its own pieces. In the La Vela cemetery at Trento, assigned to the Square-Mouthed Pottery culture and dated to the middle of the fifth millennium, Maria Angelica Borrello and Giampaolo Dalmeri describe seven cylindrical beads laid on the pelvis of a young woman of about eighteen, perhaps a belt. A child of three or four wore beads at the neck and the right wrist, with traces of cinnabar. For the authors it is the only Neolithic Spondylus assemblage in the Alpine arc. At Isorella, near Brescia, a bracelet fragment was found with a hole drilled at one end to mend it; it is now in the museum at Remedello and dated to between 4800 and 4600 BC. The southernmost beads, according to Séfériadès, come from Sicily and Malta.
The bracelet, moreover, was worn in life. In the Chirnogi cemetery in Romania, Monica Margarit and Mădălina Dimache count sixteen Spondylus bracelets in ten graves of the Gumelnița culture, from the second half of the fifth millennium. The wear marks show that they had been worn for a long time and gathered over the years before burial. The Polish pieces, too, show long use and repairs, and Kurzawska and Sobkowiak-Tabaka read them as a sign of belonging to the farming communities rather than as a mere luxury. Séfériadès rejects prestige as the whole explanation and notes a paradox, since the farther one moves from the Mediterranean, the more such objects tend to turn up. In the Karbuna hoard, in Moldova, 270 Spondylus pieces lay beside 444 copper objects.
Then the fashion ends. According to Windler's data, use declines between 5000 and 4000 BC, and after 4000 the shell appears only rarely. Séfériadès ties the end to the passing of Neolithic and Copper Age traditions. The isotopes have settled which sea the shell came from and how young it was when it was gathered. They do not say why a man at Varna, buried among gold, wore on his arm a ring of broken shell. The gold plates held it together.
References
Bajnóczi Bernadett, Schöll-Barna Gabriella, Kalicz Nándor, Siklósi Zsuzsanna, Hourmouziadis George H., Ifantidis Fotis, Kyparissi-Apostolika Aikaterini, Pappa Maria, Veropoulidou Rena, Ziota Christina, «Tracing the source of Late Neolithic Spondylus shell ornaments by stable isotope geochemistry and cathodoluminescence microscopy», Journal of Archaeological Science, 40, 2, 874–882, 2013. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jas.2012.09.022
Borrello Maria Angelica, Dalmeri Giampaolo, «Gli ornamenti preistorici lavorati in conchiglie conservati presso il Museo Tridentino di Scienze Naturali (Trento)», Preistoria Alpina, 40, supplement 1, 43–52, 2004 (published 2005).
Chapman John, Higham Tom, Slavchev Vladimir, Gaydarska Bisserka, Honch Noah, «The social context of the emergence, development and abandonment of the Varna cemetery, Bulgaria», European Journal of Archaeology, 9, 2-3, 159–183, 2006. https://doi.org/10.1177/1461957107086121
Halstead Paul, «Spondylus shell ornaments from late Neolithic Dimini, Greece: specialized manufacture or unequal accumulation?», Antiquity, 67, 256, 603–609, 1993. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0003598X00045816
Higham Tom, Chapman John, Slavchev Vladimir, Gaydarska Bisserka, Honch Noah, Yordanov Yordan, Dimitrova Branimira, «New perspectives on the Varna cemetery (Bulgaria) – AMS dates and social implications», Antiquity, 81, 313, 640–654, 2007. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0003598X00095636
Kurzawska Aldona, Sobkowiak-Tabaka Iwona, «Spondylus shells at prehistoric sites in Poland», Sprawozdania Archeologiczne, 72, 2, 41–66, 2020. https://doi.org/10.23858/SA/72.2020.2.1713
Margarit Monica, Dimache Mădălina, «Personal adornments from the Eneolithic necropolis of Chirnogi-Suvita Iorgulescu (Romania)», Documenta Praehistorica, 46, 398–413, 2019. https://doi.org/10.4312/dp.46.25
Mariottini Paolo, Smriglio Carlo, Oliverio Marco, Rossi Sabrina, Di Giulio Andrea, «Checklist of the marine malacofauna of Culuccia Peninsula (NW Sardinia, Italy), with notes on relevant species», Biodiversity Data Journal, 12, e115051, 2024. https://doi.org/10.3897/BDJ.12.e115051
Odone S., record «Bracciale, frammento» (Isorella, Bocche locality), inventory St. 108021, Museo Archeologico di Remedello, Lombardia Beni Culturali – SIRBeC, 2005. https://lombardiabeniculturali.it/reperti-archeologici/schede-complete/3l150-00023
Séfériadès Michel Louis, «Spondylus and Long-Distance Trade in Prehistoric Europe», in Anthony David W. (ed.), The Lost World of Old Europe: The Danube Valley, 5000–3500 BC, Institute for the Study of the Ancient World and Princeton University Press, New York, 178–191, 2010. https://isaw.nyu.edu/exhibitions/oldeurope/pdf/spondylus.pdf
Shackleton Nicholas, Renfrew Colin, «Neolithic Trade Routes re-aligned by Oxygen Isotope Analyses», Nature, 228, 5276, 1062–1065, 1970. https://doi.org/10.1038/2281062a0
Shackleton Nicholas J., Elderfield Henry, «Strontium isotope dating of the source of Neolithic European Spondylus shell artefacts», Antiquity, 64, 243, 312–315, 1990. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0003598X00077942
Windler Arne, «The Use of Spondylus gaederopus during the Neolithic of Europe», Journal of Open Archaeology Data, 7, 7, 2019. https://doi.org/10.5334/joad.59
Previous articles on ScienceOnline
Guido Donati, «What is archaeomalacology» ScienceOnline, 16 October 2026.
Guido Donati, «Monetaria moneta. The animal», ScienceOnline, 24 September 2026.
Guido Donati, «Monetaria moneta. Brooding» (English title to be checked), ScienceOnline, 8 October 2026.
*Board Member, SRSN (Roman Society of Natural Science)
Past Editor-in-Chief Italian Journal of Dermosurgery



